Silicon Shecky

I read a fantastic article on Tech Republic about the CCIE certification and was it losing its value. There were points in the article brought up about getting the certification and getting experience.I wanted to touch on this a bit overall as it relates to many jobs and certifications in the IT world.

Its the age old catch 22. The IT professional studies for a certification, hoping he can move up in the field to a better paying job, or a section of the field she is more interested in, and has little experience in. Then they apply for the positions and get turned down due to lack of experience in that area. Next person comes in with experience in the area, but no certification, and they get turned down for the position also. Eventually the position goes to someone who has just a little bit of experience and a college degree, and that person proceeds to prove they have no clue what they are doing.

The world of IT jobs is a tough world to live in. You need the experience and the certifications, and the college degree to become close to being wanted. Most companies force us to go through HR departments which have no clue about the actual position, and go by pieces of paper. If you can get around that, then you have to deal with the real tech interview by someone in the department you are applying.

It sucks, and it makes life difficult. Those of us in lower paying jobs can’t afford to get equipment to practice on, and practicing on a client is frowned upon. So we study for the exams, we use the virtual labs, we do whatever we can to get the knowledge. Its too bad that the experience factor is so much more difficult. If you want a job you need the experience, but how do you get the experience without a job? I know I am still searching for an answer.

I am a geek. I post here, I twitter, I read a number of tech sites. I also am a Network Engineer and have Microsoft certifications. Oh yeah, I have the CompTIA A+ and Network+ Certifications. I went with the CompTIA certifications because of the standard they are. They are entry level, and never need to be renewed, or at least that was the case for all but a few days this year.

While going through my tech news this morning, Ars Technica had an article up titled, “ Thought that A+ cert was good for life? Think again.” It talks about how CompTIA was making the entry level certifications renewable, and making it retroactive. Yes, you would have to pay a yearly fee to keep the certification plus do continuing education or take the exam over again every three years. Also if you had originally been certified over 3 years ago, you would have to take the newest version of the exam to get recertified.

The announcement was originally made back on January 11, 2010. The geek world went ballistic. Discussions on forum after forum popped up. Grass roots organizations started on Facebook. Finally, Ars Technica got a hold of the info and posted it. The embers of discontent were fanned into an even larger fire. CompTIA has backed down and made adjustments to when changes would occur.

The question is, how much has it hurt CompTIA in the computer world. Yes they are honoring the Lifetime Certifications as valid again, plus if you get the certification before the end of 2010 it will be lifetime still. The new rules take effect Jan 1, 2011.

The dropping of the ball on this was two fold. First off, CompTIA gave no forewarning that they were thinking of changing the terms of the 3 certifications (A+, Network+, Security+). The surprise factor of the announcement would have caused a large ruckus anyway, but then you had to add factor 2. They were revoking thousands, if not millions of people’s certifications. One of the first certifications most people get is the A+, because it shows a basic knowledge of the computer world. All of a sudden, the agreement we had signed saying we were getting a lifetime certification was null and void.

Don’t get me wrong, I can’t complain that they would make the exams renewable. It makes sense. Think of the people who will pass the A+ and then never use it. It is time for it to loose the lifetime certification. Cisco, Microsoft, and most of the other certifications out there expire and have to be upgraded or renewed. Time frames differ, but it makes sense. CompTIA though went about it the wrong way. CompTIA deals with enough certifications that it will survive this. The question is, will the exams affected by this PR disaster survive, and will CompTIA be looked at differently for a long time, or will this just pass into oblivion?